Workbench Designs

16

A workbench should be heavy, very heavy. So I build a lot of benches with good thick 4” tops and simple but robust bases.

Now a days we tend to call this the French bench, mainly due to recent trends in workbench designs. I don’t think the evolution of workbench designs was clear cut or defined so regionally, but there are without a doubt some features that were favoured only in particular areas. I’ve seen countless workbenches, some very early, that you could easily mistake for the ’French’ design even though this certainly wasn’t their origin. The ‘French’ bench as we know it is, after all, really only one step evolved from the very basic design used by the Romans.

So the French workbench remained simple. It could be massive, it could be petite, but it did always remain simple.

Now, if we nail a couple of deep aprons on the front and back of this ‘simple’ workbench design then what have we got?

The Nicholson – An English Tradition

The English, or Nicholson workbench design is robust, simple and well worth considering if you’re planning to build your own workbench.

The photos shown below are of an English style bench made in oak, although pine tends to be my timber of choice for this bench design.

Learn how to build a simple ‘Planked Top’, which is well suited to this English style of workbench.

Aprons on the Nicholson workbench design

 Building an English workbench

Truing the apron joint on the English workbench

fitting the aprons on the english workbench

Dry fitting the base of teh Nicholson workbench

Completed English / Nicholson workbench

The two vices on the Nicholson workbench

Nicholson bench with face vise


BUILDING YOUR OWN ENGLISH WORKBENCH? See our detailed Video Series with PDF Plans.

More Interested in the French Bench? Follow a build here.

16 Responses

  1. patrick anderson

    Now, if we nail a couple of deep aprons on the front and back of this ‘simple’ bench design then what have we got?

    A Nicholson

    Do I win the bench if I’m right? 😀

    Reply
    • Richard

      Ha, I’m affraid I can’t stretch to the bench Patrick but I like your cheek so that’s got to be worth a hand forged holdfast! Check on your emails, it’ll be on its way. 🙂

      Reply
  2. Kerry

    What is the purpose of the miter joint where the legs meet the apron? I’ve seen this as well as a regular butt joint on Nicholson benches. Is more aesthetics or purpose?

    Thanks

    Reply
    • Richard

      Kerry, that’s a really good question. I’d definately say that’s it’s none essential on any workbench today and adds a considerable amount of time to the joint. It does however add a lot more shouldered surface area than a straight joint and together with the locking fit of the angle it certainly resists rack a lot better. My gut also says that it was often done because it was known to be best rather than because it was necessary and maybe the woodworker felt that the guilds / other woodworkers would look down on them for anything other. And also as Patrick puts it, ‘it looks SO much nicer’!

      Reply
  3. patrick anderson

    Are you referring to the angled notch between the leg and apron? I would think the angled notch prevents movement better than a butt joint plus it looks SO much nicer.

    Reply
  4. George Bridgeman

    Hi Richard,

    Incredible bench! Lovely design.

    I made a very similar style bench (although much simplified and in fir – from the Paul Sellers series) and I was wondering how you attached the top to the supports? I had bearers on top of the leg frames and screwed through those and into the benchtop, along with screws through the apron into the benchtop. How did you secure the top securely?

    George.

    Reply
  5. Richard

    Hi George, on this particular bench the top was secured to the front aprons with wooden nails (or pegs) and then it was secured to the top bearers of the trestles with hand forged iron nails. The construction of this bench was in keeping with some earlier English examples however on other benches that i’ve built of this style I’ve often used lag screws. These go from underneath the bearers rather than above.
    Thanks, Richard
    p.s I’d love to see a photo of your bench!

    Reply
  6. Jason

    I am actually in the process of making a very similar bench, but I have a problem understanding how you raise and lower the dogs with the front apron being so large. Could you explain how to practically use dogs with the tail vice?

    Reply
    • Richard

      Hi Jason, That’s a good question and well observed. The English bench wasn’t designed to include a tail vice so the difficulty of raising dogs was never a concern. Usually when I build a bench of this style I’ll leave of the tail vice off for this reason although this customer was keen for it to be included. You could still include the tail vice, the dogs would just take a few extra seconds to raise although you may prefer to get it to the practise of using holdfasts and planing stops for much of your work instead.

      Reply
      • Jason

        Richard,

        Thanks for the answer, that makes a lot of sense. I will probably build my bench without a tail vise to begin with, to see if I can work without one. But if it turns out I really want one I recently stumbled across “prairie dogs” made by veritas, These seem like they would solve my problem.

        Keep up the good work. I always love reading about what is brewing in your shop (woodworking projects and tea :-P).

        Cheers!
        Jason

        Reply
  7. Jonas Jensen

    Hi Richard.

    Nice looking bench.
    It looks like it is made out of elm?
    Brgds
    Jonas (Denmark)

    Reply
  8. Bernard Naish

    What you have is an English style work bench. The aprons and top form a very rigid box section that I believe keeps the top flatter than any other method. I built mine this way because there was comment on the US blogs about how superior continental benches were and how you could not clamp work down to the top. Providing the aprons are thick enough 1 1/2 to 2 inches an “F” clamp works very well indeed with the screw end sitting on the edge of the apron. Where the apron really comes into its own is holding boards on edge for jointing

    Reply
  9. Mauricio

    Hi Richard,

    Are the bearers simply but jointed and nailed into each of the approns?

    Also, do these tops have a tendency to split? It seems like there is no allowance for the flat sawn boards of the top to expand and contract.

    Thanks

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUBSCRIBE TO POSTS